What Is Your Favorite Retelling?

In the writing community, there’s a saying that there are no new story ideas – there are around 12, and every “new” story is one of those 12 told in a different voice and from a different angle. The Orphaned Chosen One and the Unasked For Journey are two common ones.

cinderAnother “branch” of these is retellings – those stories that are new takes on old classics. They don’t pretend to be “original.” Their charm lies in the fact that they follow a known story line but in a new setting.

I love retellings. This year I read one of my new favorites, Cinder by Marissa Meyer. It’s the Cinderella story told in futuristic China and where Cinderella is a cyborg.

Another retelling that I loved is Ruby Slips and Poker Chips by Heather Kindt. It’s a new spin on The Wizard of Oz, where Dorothy is a teacher and the ruby slipswicked witch is her principal. There are analogs for the Scarecrow, Tin Man, and Cowardly Lion as well, but you have to read the book to discover what they are. I especially liked the Lion analog.

I like retellings so much I decided to write one. My latest work-in-progress is a middle-grade retelling of the Aladdin story set in a modern-day urban elementary school. It stars Alejandro (Aladdin), who with the help of his pet hedgehog (monkey), discovers a magic coin (lamp) that houses the ghost of a janitor (the genie). I even have Alejandro steal bread in the first scene.

As a side note – writing a hedgehog is super fun. Everyone should try it.

The analogs are what make retellings fun, I think. Readers have to figure out what new thing represents something from the known story. A movie that did an especially entertaining job of this was Oh Brother, Where Art Thou?, which you probably know is a retelling of a very old story, Homer’s Odyssey. I think the corrupt preacher as the cyclops was brilliant.


Credit: imdb.com

Another movie favorite is Ten Things I Hate About You, borrowed from Shakespeare’s Taming of the Shrew. In that retelling, the sisters are high-school students, and the younger, popular sister can’t date until the older, jaded one does.

ten things

Credit: thesun.com

There’s even a not-so-subtle nod to The Bard himself in the secondary characters, one of which claims to be in a relationship with him.

10 Things I Hate About You Films GIF - Find & Share on GIPHY

I’m not sure that would have worked if the story hadn’t been a retelling. It might have been the only reason that part was there.

I’ve had the floor long enough, so now it’s your turn. What do you think of retellings? What great ones have you read/watched?

12 thoughts on “What Is Your Favorite Retelling?

  1. I love ten things I hate about you.
    I agree with Allison though Dan, there’s only so many stories.
    I just had this arguement with the hubs. We watched Guardians of the Galaxy with the kiddo and I said he’d like Star Trek, it’s just like this. And I managed to argue the plot similarities sufficiently to get the hubs to agree. LOL

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Ruby Slips is probably my current fave, as far as retellings go.

    I’m not sure about the “only 12 stories” thing. I suppose if you look at a story from a far enough distance, you can say it looks like something else – but that also means you already know the 12 stories and are observing at twenty thousand feet. From there, cars look like ants. That’s not even close to correct if the effort is taken to observe either from a normal perspective.

    12 Stories Guy: Die Hard is like the Adam and Eve story.

    Normal Person: What? No it’s not. Die Hard is a Christmas party where the guy’s wife is taken hostage and euro bad guys steal a bunch of bonds.

    12: it has a girl and a guy

    Norm: and explosions and a bad @ss beat down and a really cool shootout…

    12: and at the end they leave the place

    Norm: but-but… no, see, it’s not similar at all…

    12: uh huh

    Liked by 1 person

Share your thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s